So after a great suggestion I decided that we will go ahead and initiate a random judge panel to help aid in deciding the winners for COTW and S&D.


How it will work.

1. You sign up here (reply and I will add you to the list) to be a potential judge.
(Judges can not enter a COTW they are judging, but you will be awarded points.)

2. When a new COTW or S&D is started 3 judges will be picked at random.
(I myself, will always be a judge so there will be 4 total).

3. Judges for the contest will get 100 points for participating.
(If you are a judge and are late or do not fulfill your commitment, no points will be given to you.)

4. Judges will go through the contest they are assigned to and pick 4 of their favorite videos (or videos they think is best).

5. They will give those 4 videos points (between 1 to 5, 5 being perfect) and PM them to NowWeCanMakeWar.

6. I (war) will do the same and add up all points. The person with the most points is declared the winner.

Example

War, Judge1, Judge 2, Judge 3

War's Judging
Contestant 1 - 4
Contestant 2 - 3
Contestant 3 - 5
Contestant 4 - 4

Judge 1
Contestant 1 - 3
Contestant 2 - 2
Contestant 3 - 5
Contestant 4 - 4

Judge 2
Contestant 1 - 4
Contestant 2 - 4
Contestant 3 - 4
Contestant 4 - 4

Judge 3
Contestant 1 - 5
Contestant 2 - 3
Contestant 3 - 3
Contestant 4 - 4

Totals:
Contestant 1 - 16
Contestant 2 - 12
Contestant 3 - 17
Contestant 4 - 16

Winner: Contestant #3.

This allows the judging to be fair as possible and random.

Judge List
Please ask to be on or removed from the judge list. This list is what will be used to pick judges randomly.

LIST AS OF APRIL 17TH 2010:

NowWeCanMakeWar
Midnight
Monk
nubmarine1
hoss
kickflippirate
gizzler
airfenza
paulgary
schnavolda
moose noodles
sevenplyjoyride
tnofilms
cerebus
thepunisher420
supafly
iamaaran
perm
Enjoi_Spac3_Ag3
cookiesupporter
adda89ldn
sk8nate11
bloodymagicteam
Oddity

if you don't want to be on the list anymore just send a short pm or write here.

The judge panel will start with S&D 008 and will be used for all COTWs/S&D's after!

I'll help out with this

ill help as well.

ill help on judging

I would love to help judge the COTW, SnD not so much because I usually like to participate

List updated! Thanks guys!

i want to be a judge too ofc.

count me in

I'm down to judge